Now that I’ve posted the Bill Whittle piece on the so-called Ground Zero Mosque, here’s a bit of balance:
- The mosque is not at ground zero. It’s a few blocks away.
- It will very likely be viewed as a triumph for Islam. It’s a religion like any other and religions cling to symbols. This will be a very powerful symbol.
- We have churches and synagogues next to playgrounds.
The rules — the law — says anyone has a right to build pretty much anything where ever they like. There’s no law that says they can’t build a mosque two blocks away. In fact, they have every right to build it.
The counter argument of “Just because you have a right doesn’t mean you should” is illogical. Exercise your rights. All of them. A right not exercised is a right that will soon be forgotten.
And, for what it’s worth, here’s Jon Stewart’s take. Watch the whole thing.
While I have been so far unable to locate the official transcript of the speech that Charlton Heston gave in 1999, I was able to find an unofficial transcript — though a video would be far, far more impressive for me:
Charlton Heston’s address to Denver NRA meeting
By Charlton Heston
May 1, 1999.
Thank you. Thank you very much.
I am very happy to welcome you to this abbreviated annual gathering of the National Rifle Association. Thank you all for coming and thank you for supporting your organization.
I also want to applaud your courage in coming here today. Of course, you have a right to be here.
As you know, we’ve canceled the festivities and the fellowship we normally enjoy at our annual gatherings. This decision has perplexed a few and inconvenienced thousands. As your president, I apologize for that.
But it is fitting and proper that we should do this. Because NRA members are, above all, Americans. That means that whatever our differences, we are respectful of one another, and we stand united, especially in adversity.
I have a message from the mayor, Mr. Wellington Webb, the mayor of Denver. He sent me this. It says, “Don’t come here. We don’t want you here.”
I say to the mayor, well, my reply to the mayor is, “I volunteered for the war they wanted me to attend when I was eighteen years old. Since then, I have run small errands for my country, from Nigeria to Vietnam.” I know many of you here in this room could say the same thing.
But the mayor said, “Don’t come.”
I’m sorry for that. I’m sorry for the newspaper ads saying the same thing, “don’t come here.”
This is our country. As Americans, we are free to travel wherever we want, in our broad land.
They say we’ll create a media distraction. But we were preceded here by hundreds of intrusive news crews.
They say we’ll create political distraction. But it’s not been the NRA pressing for political advantage, calling press conferences to promote vast new packages of legislation.
Still they say, “Don’t come here.”
I guess what saddens me the most is how that suggests complicity. It implies that you and I and 80 million honest gun owners are somehow to blame. That we don’t care as much as they do. Or that we don’t deserve to be as shocked and horrified as every other soul in America mourning for the people of Littleton.
Don’t come here. That’s offensive. It’s also absurd. Because we live here.
There are thousands of NRA members in Denver and tens upon tens of thousands in the state of Colorado. NRA members labor in Denver’s factories, they populate Denver’s faculties, run Denver corporations, play on Colorado’s sports teams, work in media and across the front range, parent and teach and coach Denver’s children, attend Denver’s churches and proudly represent Denver in uniform on the world’s oceans and in the skies over Kosovo at this very moment. NRA members are in City Hall, Fort Carson, NORAD, the Air Force Academy, and the Olympic training center. And yes, NRA members are surely among the police and fire and SWAT team heroes who risked their lives to rescue the students at Columbine.
Don’t come here? We’re already here! This community is our home. Every community in America is our home.
We are a 128-year-old fixture of mainstream America.
The Second Amendment ethic of lawful, responsible firearm ownership spans the broadest cross section of American life imaginable. So, we have the same rights as all other citizens to be here. To help shoulder the grief, to share our sorrow and to offer our respectful, reassured voice to the national discourse that has erupted around this tragedy.
One more thing: Our words and our behavior will be scrutinized more than ever this morning. Those who are hostile towards us will lie in wait to seize on a sound bite out of context, ever searching for an embarrassing moment to ridicule us. So, let us be mindful. The eyes of the nation are on us today.
[other speakers are introduced — Heston later continues]
I see our country teetering on the edge of an abyss. At its bottom brews the simmering bile of deep, dark hatred. Hatred that is dividing our country. Politically. Racially. Geographically. In every way, whether it’s political vendettas, sports brawls, corporate takeovers, high school gangs and cliques.
The American competitive ethic has changed from “let’s beat the other guy” to “let’s destroy the other guy.” Too many, too many are too willing to stigmatize and demonize others for political advantage, for money or for ratings. The vilification is savage.
This week, Representative John Conyers slandered 3 million Americans when he called the NRA “merchants of death” on national television, as our first lady nodded in agreement.
A hideous editorial cartoon by Mike Peters ran nationally. It showed children’s dead bodies sprawled out to spell NRA.
The countless requests we’ve received in the last week or so for media appearances are in fact summons to public floggings, where those who hate firearms will predictably don the white hat and give us the black one.
This harvest of hatred is then sold as news, as entertainment, as government policy.
Such hateful, divisive forces are leading us to one awful end: America’s own form of Balkanization. A weakened country of rabid factions each less free, united only by hatred of one another.
In the past 10 days we’ve seen these brutal blows attempting to fracture America into two such camps. One camp would be the majority, people who believe our Founders guaranteed our security with the right to defend ourselves, our families, and our country. The other camp would be a large minority of people who believe that we will buy security if we will just surrender these freedoms.
This debate would be accurately described as those who believe in the Second Amendment versus those who don’t. But instead it is spun as those who believe in murder versus those who don’t. The struggle between the reckless and the prudent.
Between the dim-witteds and the progressives.
Between inferior citizens who don’t know and elitists who know what’s good for society.
But we’re not the rustic reckless radicals they wish for. No, the NRA spans the broadest range of American demography imaginable. We defy stereotype, except for love of country.
Look in your mirror, your shopping mall, your church or grocery store. That’s us. Millions of ordinary people and extraordinary people. War heroes, sports idols, several U.S. presidents, and yes, movie stars.
But the screeching hyperbole leveled at gun owners has made these two camps so wary of each other, so hostile, and confrontational and disrespectful. On both sides. It is forgotten that we are first, Americans.
I am asking all of us on both sides to take one step back from the edge. Then another step. And another. However many it takes to get back to that place where we are all Americans. Different, imperfect, diverse, but one nation, indivisible.
This cycle of tragedy-driven hatred must stop. Because so much more connects us than that which divides us. And because tragedy has been and will always be with us.
Somewhere right now evil people are planning evil things. All of us will do everything meaningful, everything we can do to prevent it. But each horrible act can’t become an axe for opportunists to cleave the very bill of rights that binds us.
America must stop this predictable pattern of reaction. When an isolated terrible event occurs, our phones ring demanding that the NRA explain the inexplicable.
Why us? Because their story needs a villain. They want us to play the heavy in their drama of packaged grief. To provide riveting programming to run between commercials for cars and cat food. The dirty secret of this day and age is that political gain and media ratings all too often bloom on fresh graves.
I remember a better day when no one dared politicize or profiteer on drama. We kept a respectful distance then, as the NRA has tried to do now. Simply being silent is so often the right thing to do.
But today carnage comes with a catchy title, splashy graphics, regular promos, and a reactionary passage of legislation.
Reporters perch like vultures on the balconies of hotels for a hundred miles around. Cameras jockey for shocking angles, as news anchors race to drench their microphones with the tears of victims. Injury, shock, grief and despair shouldn’t be brought to you by sponsors. That’s pornography. It trivializes the tragedy it abuses. It abuses vulnerable people, and maybe worst of all, it makes the unspeakable seem commonplace.
We are often cast as the villain. That is not our role in American society, and we will not be forced to play it.
Our mission is to remain, as our vice-president said, a steady beacon of strength and support for the Second Amendment, even if it has no other friend on this planet.
We cannot — we must not — let tragedy lay waste to the most rare and hard-won human right in history.
A nation cannot gain safety by giving up freedom. This truth is older than our country. “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.” Ben Franklin said that.
Now, if you like your freedoms of speech, and of religion, freedom from search and seizure, freedom of the press, and of privacy and to assemble, and to redress grievances, then you better give them the eternal bodyguard called the Second Amendment. The individual right to bear arms is freedom’s insurance policy. Not just for your children, but for infinite generations to come. That is its singular sacred beauty, and why we preserve it so fiercely.
No, it’s not a right without rational restrictions. And it’s not for everyone. Only the law-abiding majority of society deserves the Second Amendment. Abuse it once, and lose it forever. That’s the law.
But, curiously, the NRA is far more eager to prosecute gun abusers than are those who oppose gun ownership all together. As if the tool could be more evil than the evil doers. I don’t understand that.
The NRA also spends more and works harder than anybody in America to promote safe, responsible use of firearms. From 38,000 certified instructors, training millions of police, hunters, women and youth, to 500 law enforcement agencies promoting our Eddie Eagle gun safety program Wayne told you about, distributed to 11 million kids, 11 million and counting.
But our essential reason for being is this: as long as there is a Second Amendment, evil can never conquer us. Tyranny in any form can never find footing within a society of law abiding, armed, ethical people. The majesty of the Second Amendment that our Founders so divinely created and crafted to your birth right guarantees that no government despot, no renegade faction of armed forces, no roving gangs of criminals, no breakdown of law and order, no massive anarchy, no force of evil or crime, or oppression from within or from without, can ever rob you of the liberties that define your Americanism.
So, when they ask you, “Well, indeed, you would bear arms against government tyranny?” The answer is: “No. That could never happen precisely because we have the Second Amendment.”
Let me be absolutely clear. The Founding Fathers guaranteed this freedom because they knew no tyranny could ever arise among a people endowed with the right to keep and bear arms. That’s why you and your descendants need never fear fascism, refugee camps, brainwashing, ethnic cleansing, or especially submission to the wanton will of criminals.
The Second Amendment: there could be no more precious inheritance. Now, that’s what the NRA preserves.
Now, if you disagree, that’s your right. I respect that. But we will not relinquish it or be silenced about it, or be told, “Do not come here. You are unwelcome in your own land.”
Let us go from this place, from this huge room, renewed in spirit and dedicated against hatred. We have work to do, hearts to heal, evil to defeat, and a country to unite. We may have differences, and we will again suffer tragedy almost beyond description. But when the sun sets on Denver tonight, and forever more, let it always set on We, the People. Secure in our land of the free and home of the brave.
I for one plan to do my part, thank you.
I, too, will do my part.